This is the seventh of eleven reflections on Thomas Merton’s teaching on the True Self/False Self dynamic. This conflictual but enlightening relationship permeates Merton’s huge quantity of writing on the spiritual life. The basic point of the conflict is the individual’s pull toward and away from God, one’ true and ultimate destiny. Merton’s exposure of the consequences of original sin is ruthless in its intensity. This is the task of the False Self. At the same time, the pull of the True Self, the ever-present call of God’s personal and passionate love, is even more powerful. The human heart is the battlefield of this seemingly endless confrontation.When Jesus began his public ministry, the universal longing for the Messiah was the dominant reality. The question of what kind of Messiah soon became a defining element in Jesus’ life and ministry.
Jesus knew that the intensity and depth of the universal conflict of good and evil would demand that he become a suffering Messiah. As early as Mk3:6 the leaders of all sides began to plot for his death. This has become the life-giving mystery of the Christian message. When Jesus proclaimed, “the Kingdom of God is at hand. Repent and believe the gospel.” (Mk.1:15) few were ready to accept the Crucified Messiah as the centerpiece of that Good News of God’s love.
There was a second major obstacle to Jesus’ proclamation of the Kingdom. The people were anticipating a complete transformation by the sudden burst of God’s saving activity. Jesus had a different plan. He insisted that his followers be part of this divine transformation by taking up their cross and following him. This had startling implications in Jesus’ day as it does in our day. It calls for deep seated changes in how we see reality.
Transformation of Consciousness
As we continue pondering the True Self/False Self dynamic to enter more deeply into the gospel, we have seen the vital importance of self-knowledge. An important part of self-knowledge is to surface and change the values that create on our worldview. This clearly is part of the ongoing conversion process. This is called the transformation of consciousness. This is an activity of raising up and challenging false values within our mindset. Most often, these are values that we inherit and embrace with minimal awareness. They are part of our culture and ambiance. They mostly fall under the umbrella of what we call conventional wisdom.Most of Jesus’ teaching was to challenge this conventional wisdom. His teachings and his life and death put the emphasis on God rather than self. This is at the heart of the True Self/False Self dynamic.
In this inherited worldview of conventional wisdom, mostly contrary to the gospel, we are engulfed in hidden prejudices and distortions. We are bombarded by values incompatible with the gospel. We are presented with false idols, sometimes obscure, but often clearly evident in their call to self-indulgence. We are told the right patterns of consumption will guarantee our control of reality, give us the assurance of youth, allow us to determine the future not to mention advancing our ability to deny death and to secure true and lasting happiness with the right credit card, the correct medicines and wise investments.
Something as simple as watching a sporting event or a weekly TV program offers an onslaught of consumer initiatives secretly enticing us away from the message of Jesus. We are in a very challenging situation where we have seemingly countless encounters with the consumer, indulgent and materialistic message. This is in contrast to the hour or so on Sunday, if we still attend church. For most of us, this is the only organized time we open our life to the gospel story and values.
The hidden power behind the conventional wisdom results in a false consciousness. This distorted view of reality accepts the gross neglect of the poor and marginalized, blinds us to the dehumanization of excessive consumption, trivializes a need for openness in community reducing it, often, to fear and exclusion of “the other”, draws us into an indifference toward the ongoing devastation of God’s creation for economic gain, and supports a widespread denial of death that genuinely distorts the reality of our creaturehood.
These are just a few of the many factors that nurture a worldview in constant conflict with the message of Jesus. It truly models the eternal battle of the True Self and the False Self.
The only place we will find freedom from the incessant offensive of false values is to return to the gospel. We are in constant need to renew and enhance our acceptance of Jesus’ call, “Repent and believe the Gospel!”
All of Jesus’ teaching calls for his disciples to share in his saving activity to bring about the long-awaited Kingdom of God. All his teaching leads to a personal transformation and participation in the basic battle between good and evil. The lessons of the gospel reversal where “the first shall be last…” (Mk 9:35). “to save your life you must lose your life” (Mk 8:35), “whoever wishes to be great among you will be your servant” (Mk 10:43) demand deep personal change and commitment far removed from the conventional wisdom of our day or any day. Likewise, the message of ever-expanding inclusion in “the least of my brothers or sisters…” (Mt 25:40), and the Good Samaritan (LK 10:29-37) demand active involvement in the Kingdom’s coming.
Jesus was clear. The battle of the True Self and False Self, of the weeds and the wheat will continue to the end (Mt 13:24-30). The disciple’s task is to let one’s life be a witness to bring love, light, truth and healing to a world caught in the darkness, isolation, division and destruction of hatred and selfishness.
The coming of the Kingdom continues in the faithful commitment of all followers of Christ and people of good will. Wherever there is love, there is the continuing conquest of hate, division, prejudice and all that dehumanizes. Wherever there is love, no matter how small and hidden, it is like the seed that is the smallest of seeds that blossoms into the tree for all the birds of the sky. (Mt 13:31-32).
The life lived in fidelity to the Gospel will bring God’s love to a broken world. (Jn 15). This fidelity to the Christian mission is sharing in the saving love of God. This is the ultimate reality of overcoming evil by the ever-expanding presence of love in the human heart. This
love demands service and responsible action. This love has no meaning without concern for the poor and needy. The Christian community will always be expanding the boundaries to include the forsaken and forgotten. There will be action but this action must be rooted in love to bring about God’s victory over evil. This happens as the True Self reigns within us individually and with ever-growing influence in our world. All this will not happen without deep personal prayer.















