John’s Dark Night and Teresa’s Message
Part One
John and Teresa are clear on most basic points in their understanding of the spiritual life. Teresa, however, places the foundation on prayer while John identifies freedom of desire. There is much agreement beyond these two points.
This includes liberation from attachment, self-knowledge and realization of one’s true identity in God. Teresa considers the process of self-knowledge right from the beginning in her description of the spiritual journey. Since John says little about the beginning, his treatment commences with the opening to the contemplative experience in the Dark Night.
“The first and chief benefit of this dry and dark night of contemplation causes is knowledge of self and one’s own misery…the difficulty encountered in the practice of virtue makes the soul recognize its own lowliness and the misery which was not apparent in the time of prosperity.” (1.12.2)
John points out three critical blessings flowing from a newly acquired self-knowledge. The first is that self-sufficiency is an illusion. The truth of our total dependence on God becomes a source of true freedom. As we become open to the true consequences of our mortality, we achieve a more realistic relation with ourselves. Finally, the humility that self-knowledge generates, opens our eyes to new and beautiful truths about God and our brothers and sisters.
The purifying grace of the Dark Night experience opens up great possibilities to truly love our neighbor. In the stages of early prayer, propped up by consolations, the strong tendency is to be judgmental of our neighbor. We are strongly inclined to focus on their faults and lack of spirituality.
In the Dark Night’s healing experience of God, we are drawn into a great irony. The gift of humility leads us to embrace the publican by the acknowledgement of our sinfulness. We forsake the self-righteousness of the Pharisee that had been our operating mode. (Lk 18:11-12)
By keeping our eyes on Jesus and being faithful to prayer, we are gifted to see with a gospel vision. We begin to both understand and embrace the true beauty of God’s presence in our sisters and brothers. A newly self-critical vision, an empowering self-knowledge, gives us new eyes. Now we can accurately grasp Mt 25 and the least of our brothers and sisters. (Dark Night 1.12.7-8)
The great gift of the Dark Night’s healing in this early stage happens in this way. In self-knowledge, we experience our weakness and moral blindness. This frees us for the driven need to judge others. Now we become accepting and compassionate for their troubling human condition. This is a gift drawing us closer to God.
John concludes that we will not know God unless we know ourselves. Teresa sees the same truth from another perspective. She states that we will never know ourselves unless we know God. Whatever the order, self-knowledge and knowing God belong together.
Finding God Begins with Self-Knowledge
Self-knowledge demands an unremitting pursuit for a deeper and more extensive awareness of our personal reality. The burdens and advantages of self-knowledge will never be depleted in this lifetime. Learning what honestly is taking place within us is a task that is never completed. One way of getting insight into the search for self-knowledge is seeing the conflict in our lives as a struggle between the false self and the true self, between sin and grace.The false self involves layer after layer of self-deception, delusions and a sense of self-grandiosity that places us at the center of our world. We tend to become blinded to our faults and failures and, more importantly, to the presence of God at the true center of our being. We emphasize the shortcomings of others.
Jesus put it ever so clearly when he pointed our blindness to a log in our eye rather than our stress on the splinter in our neighbor’s eye. (Mt 7:3) Self-righteousness controls our worldview. As we become aware of the false values flowing from our fragmented heart, we find ourselves facing a fork in the road.
We have a choice of life or death. We choose death when we double down on the clamoring of the false self for more attention. We choose life when we open ourselves to the mercy of God which draws us toward the true self. At the heart of this decision is the perennial challenge of knowing ourselves.
Teresa of Avila never stopped proclaiming the significance of self- knowledge for the path to God in the center of our being. In one of her many statements on self-knowledge she said: “Well now, it is foolish to think that we will enter heaven without entering ourselves, reflecting on our misery and what we owe God and begging Him often for mercy.” (IC 2.1.11)
There are numerous gospel passages that point out this practice of leaving the false self of our self-centeredness and moving on to the true self which is seeking God at our center. In Mark we read: “If anyone wants to be first, he must make himself last of all.” (Mk 9:35) Matthew tells us: “Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it.” (Mt 10:39) Again, John says: “Unless a grain of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it remains a grain of wheat, but if it dies, it produces much fruit.” (Jn 12:24) Finally, Matthew adds: “Whoever wishes to come after me must deny himself, take up his cross and follow me.” (Mt 16:24)
Conversion
The slow process of growing in self-knowledge leads to a gradual development of personal transformation called conversion. It is repeated at several stages of spiritual growth. The journey to discover and accept the true self, leading to God at the center, is only possible when we acknowledge our sinfulness and pettiness.Once again, this process includes humility as essential to our growth in prayer and away from self-centeredness. To face ourselves with honesty is a challenging task. It is not a joyful part of our growth. The price tag for faithfulness to God drives away the timid and comfortable. All prayer must begin with a sense of the loving presence of God.
When we accept the challenge of the divine presence, there is the bridge between our heart and our life. This call to conversion always joins God’s loving call, our acceptance of our poverty and our determination move on to the true self.